Collection: Made to Order

We are no longer able to take special color requests, such as requests to match a specific toy color, exact skin tone, past order, or reference photo. Our pigments are highly concentrated, which makes exact color matching extremely difficult, even when trying to match our own previous work. Because this has led to customer expectations not being met, all colors must be selected from our available color options.

Shop Made to Order by Style

To make browsing easier, our Made to Order collection is now organized into four style categories:

Straight Sleeves – Designed with a more traditional, direct shape and a neutral fit.

Curved Sleeves – Built with an upward curve for customers looking for a more shaped, angled design.

Fantasy Sleeves – More exaggerated, creative, or non-traditional designs for those looking for something outside the standard realistic style.

Headless Sheaths – Shorter, headless designs made for customers who want added girth, texture, or coverage without a full sleeve head.

You can browse the full Made to Order collection below, or choose the style that best fits what you’re looking for.

Experience the ultimate in personalization with our Made to Order collection. Each piece is handcrafted to your selected specifications, giving you control over the details that matter most.

Choose from a variety of options, including:

Density: Tailor the firmness or flexibility for your ideal feel.

Available densities:

00-50 – Firm: our firmest silicone
00-30 – Balanced: soft, yet supportive
00-20 – Soft: flexible with a softer feel
00-10 – Extra Soft: the softest silicone we offer. This material may cure with a slightly tacky finish.

Length: Select the size that works best for you.

Fit: Choose the internal fit that’s most comfortable for your body.

Colors: Explore our available color options to create a product that reflects your style.

Finish: Choose from our standard finish or Mr Slick Finish.

At Mr Slick Willies, we’re dedicated to delivering handcrafted quality with a made-for-you experience.